But its not just the endless pages of detailed, horrific crimes that keeps me awake at night. Im Scott Benjamin, and everything Im about to tell you is real. Then it all began to fall apart. Carole Hoff was the second wife of John Wayne Gacy, Jr., the serial killer who confessed to sexually molesting and murdering more than 30 boys and young men. In this episode, Michael Drane, UPC's To help cope with the pain her husband caused, Masonbegan writing; in 2017, shepublisheda book, Green River Serial Killer: Biography of an Unsuspecting Wife,co-written with PennieMorehead. Doctor Psycho is a odcast thst searches the broken underbelly of society, shining a light on more neglected topics. Herb and Julie Baumeister met while attending college together at Indiana University in 1967. [00:04:30] He was arrested for drinking and driving in Rochester, Indiana, and sentenced to three days in jail in one year of probation. Hes nice. From Iheartradio and Tenderfoot TV, Monster presents INSOMNIAC. Herbs family had noted anti-social behavior in Herb since he was a child. On his iPhone is a recording taken by one of the paranormal investigators who toured the property, of what they claim is Herb Baumeisters voice saying that he took a pipe to the skulls of his victims. [00:20:30] The Baumeisters called their new thrift store Save A Lot, not to be confused with the chain of grocery stores that go by a similar name, and it was initially successful. There are instances of this in novels and movies too, and dating much earlier. The only witnesses to his brutal and unusual crimes were the mannequins and they arent talking. [00:04:00] On July 2nd, 1996, a Canadian trooper cautiously approached the driver of the vehicle parked under a bridge. So why mannequins? Everyone thought he eventually got it together. When he was younger, he worked as a copy boy at the Indianapolis Star, during which time he and a friend also co-owned a secondhand hearse. WebJulie Baumeister Communications & Events Coordinator at Great River Greening; Richfield Foundation Board Member & Secretary Minneapolis, MN. In one gruesome display, he cut off a victim's breast and made a mold of it to use asa paperweight. The next several years werent much better for Herb either. I feel like Im aging a lot faster than I ever have before. Dennis, known as the BTK killer for his method of bind, torture, kill, murdered at least 10 women from 1974 to 1991. Herb replied that it was a relic of his deceased fathers medical career. Both of his Save-A-Lot stores had now failed and had closed their doors for good. The search ended up taking two weeks. I know it sounds like a dream to some of you, and I thought it might be too. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! August 15, 2017. But its something I have to do. Probably carried away by animals. She thought to herself. Music composed by Makeup and Vanity Set, and cover art by Trevor Eiler. During the time that the I-70 killings were committed, Herb and Julie Baumeister had been married for a little over 10 years. There would be no trial. WebJuliane Bauermeister, Berlin: Berufserfahrung, Kontaktdaten, Portfolio und weitere Infos: Erfahr mehr oder kontaktier Juliane Bauermeister direkt bei XING. Julie was justifiably freaked out. The 11,000 square-foot house features an indoor swimming pool, a five-car garage, stained glass windows, and two libraries. These are the cases that have kept me awake for the past few years. Theres something more. A wife's response to her husband'sserial crimes can range from denial to disbelief, with some spouses harboring suspicions, and others refusing to believe they marrieda murderer. According to IndyStar archives, Baumeister, 49, was the owner of Sav-A-Lot thrift stores. In the years since, authorities have linked him to an additional five deaths. She said in an interview, Our biggest question now is how he could have loved us and done this., Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb, Horror Movies That Don't Look Like Horror Movies. But in [00:17:30] adolescents, he started developing antisocial behaviors. All right, so Im going home from work now and its about, its about five oclock. Related: The Brutal Case of BTK Serial Killer Dennis Rader. Harris claimed Briantook him to a large estate, and the twoengaged in autoerotic asphyxiation. Im exhausted, but at the same time, cant sleep. The man noted that Smart was driving a gray Buick with [00:10:00] Ohio license plates. Robinson proposed to Lynchduring one of their first dates. Though Paula has never made an official statement, her daughter Kerri Rawson came forward in 2014 and contended the family never knew Dennis was responsible for the murders. In 1998, a witness identified a photo of Herb Baumeister, saying that he had seen Baumeister leaving an Indianapolis nightclub with Michael Riley in 1983. He finished his long note with the line that he simply wanted to eat a peanut butter sandwich, his favorite snack, and then go to sleep. When Herb went away by himself for a vacation in June 1996, police showed up andasked Julie'spermission to search the property, which she granted. Did they know about their spouses' double lives? Somewhere with a lot of property and privacy [00:21:30] where Herb could conduct a different kind of business. 18 others named Julie Do you remember that stack of videotapes the Canadian troopers saw in Herbs backseat the day before he killed himself? Even if you dont believe in ghosts, Taylor told the New York Daily News, there is no denying that a sinister pall hangs over this farm, if for no other reason than it was a place where evil once lived.. Fox Hollow Farm ranks among its most popular destinations, said Troy Taylor, American Hauntings founder. Once there, Brian had insisted that they participate in autoerotic asphyxiation, what Tony called a strangulation fetish thing, with the aid of a pool hose, an activity which Tony said had gone too far and almost cost him his life. There also happened to be a dead raccoon on the road. All right reserved. Rader's arrest took place in 2005 after authorities suspected him of being the BTK("Bind, Torture, Kill") Killer,Dietz told police her husband was a good man, a great father. She wasnt able to see Herbs day-to-day activities and it gave him plenty of freedom to use the house, and in particular the indoor pool, any way he wanted. By 1991, however, the stores struggled to make a profit, which took a toll on the Baumeisters' marriage. The anxiety, the lack of energy during the day, falling asleep at my office desk in the middle of the afternoon, trouble concentrating on anything, and then extremely restless sleep when I do drift off in the evenings. In 1988, Herb borrowed seed money from his mother to start his first Sav-A-Lot thrift store. Goodlet had gone missing in July of 1994. The couple maintained a faade of a happy marriage and profitable business for years. Its a very strange interview. People who knew Baumeister as a child said he was always an oddball, uneasy with people and known for behavior that was just plain weird. On further inspection, the pair found a pile of bones - if reassembled it would make a fully formed human skeleton. The victims were: By the time an arrest warrant was issued for Herb Baumeister, he had disappeared. Well play the audio for you in a moment. In the fall of 1994, Julie Baumeisters son Erichthe middle of three children she shared with her husband Herb Baumeisterbrought her a human skull. When she asked where hed found it, he said that he got it in the woods of their 18-acre estate, Fox Hollow Farm, a few miles outside Indianapolis. Julie then remembered her son bringing home a skullhe had found while playing on their property. The victims, all of whom hailed from Indianapolis, were found strangled to death, their nude or partially-nude bodies dumped into shallow streams along the I-70 corridor. In May of 1993, Indianapolis police began receiving missing person reports. Apparently this angered Herb so much that he decided to take photographs of what he witnessed and share them with the local news station to alert them to this wrongdoing. If Ive been asked to keep quiet about something, I do. Hoff allegedly would often complain to Gacy about the awful smell emanating from below the house, which Gacy dismissed as a moisture buildup in the crawl space. But I wouldnt necessarily call it entertaining anymore or fun or relaxing in any way. Perhaps aware of his imminent arrest, he had fled to Canada, where his body was found on July 3, lying just outside his car in Pinery Provincial Park. All of this is really just [00:16:00] the tip of the iceberg. The two had been married since 1971. Dame Julie Walters has revealed she was diagnosed with stage three bowel cancer. Even if you dont believe in ghosts, Taylor told the Daily News, there is no denying that a sinister pall hangs over this farm, if for no other reason than it was a place where evil once lived., The 2023 Met Galas Karl Lagerfeld theme evokes criticism and controversy for some, Public defenders need decent pay: New York City is paying cops even more as lawyers for the poor fall further behind, Aiding NYCs seniors this month and every month: Highlighting the Adams administrations Cabinet for Older New Yorkers, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. He lacked a sense of propriety and his timing and judgment were off. By 1965, Herb had graduated high school and was accepted into Indiana University. the estate to build a case against Herb in connection with the multiple disappearances of gay men in the Indianapolis area. Herb Baumeister The I-70 Strangler The I-70 Strangler Scour the web for the tale of the I-70 Strangler, and the mannequins are always a footnote. They just decided to take some stuff out of old files, dust it off and say we solved this, Ted Fleischaker, the publisher of a newspaper serving the Indianapolis gay community, told the Associated Press. Herb went missing the day after the search started, and authorities found his body eight days later lying beside his car in a park. Newscaster: Herb [00:27:00] Baumeister of Carmel saw it all. His wife, his children, the authorities, and everyone else really, were about to learn the secrets that Herb kept hidden at Fox Hollow Farm. [00:01:30] Unfortunately, I believe thats been tarnished for the same reason as well. Brian Smart turned out to be Herb Baumeister. No matter what it takes. He was finally apprehended in the winter of 2005 after he accidentally incriminated himself while sending taunting letters to the police. Were they scared to go to the police? He had shot himself and left a three-page suicide note, but he did not mention the murders he was believed to have committed. Did they not care? Then Her [00:15:30] The summer week she spent away from home didnt help matters either. Three months later, the couplemarried,expected their first child, and moved to Kansas City, MO. One notable arrest in his past came after police had found him in an ally behind a womans clothing store with three mannequins, [00:15:30] all were dressed in lingerie. The house they drove to was a large tutor style home, and the pair entered from a side door. Following a tip from an informant, one that wanted to remain anonymous, the hunt for another man, someone known as Brian Smart [00:09:00] was on. While working at the Bureau of Motor Vehicles from 1974 until 1985, Herb Baumeister managed to work his way up to the rank of Program Director, but his coworkers also noted odd behavior, including one report of him urinating on a letter addressed to the governor or possibly on the desk of his supervisor. Youll undoubtedly hear about Herb Baumeisters several murders, or the boys he cultivated then lured home. He never explained why he left his fathers old medical skeleton in the backyard, and Julie never asked. It affects my home life, and to some degree, its even changed my physical appearance. Hoff was a newdivorce and had two daughters from her previous marriage. Im supposed to be writing. Im certainly not doing anything criminal in real life, nor do I ever want to. Most killers arent very open about their murdering ways, and thats with good reason. When police showed up a Judith Mawsons house in late 2001 and informed her that her husband Gary Ridgway had been arrested in connection with the Green River Killer case, she was in complete shock. Thats what shes always claimed, and thats what we have to believe until we hear otherwise. It seems like Julie spent as much time keeping the kids away from Herb as possible. She told "Dateline, "Especially when he said he was going hunting, and he was dressed up nice and had cologne on. I wanted to make a joke at the [city] council meeting and say that we hope we dont find any bones while were building, but I decided to keep it professional, Herron told the Indianapolis Star. Youll undoubtedly hear about Herb Baumeisters several murders, or the boys he cultivated then lured home. Additionally, he started leaving magazines around the home featuring naked men and boys. In 1978, 27 bodies turned up in Gacy's crawl space, which led to the killer's arrest. For more podcasts from [00:22:00] iHeart Radio, visit the iHeart Radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. He started playing with dead animals, and friends remember him speaking of wondering what it would be like to taste human urine. Theres no indication in the video as to what year the interview took place, but I have it figured to be between 1991 and 1994. Theres the Greek myth of Pygmalion, the sculptor who fell in love with the statue he had carved. You might think thats bad enough, but it gets worse. All the while she knew that someone was buried in the woods behind the house. Baumeister was 44 years old and he and his wife, Julies, small Save-A-Lot chain of thrift stores was successful [00:03:00] enough to allow them to buy a new home, a mansion north of the city. Youre going to learn how the I70 Strangler found a way around this dilemma. If somebody has any information, wed be happy to look at it, Hancock County Sheriff James Bradbury said of the case. WebPostlewaite, Philip F.; Sheffield, Jeff ; Baumeister, Julie et al. They found the bodies of 11 men, and identified eight of them. I had my Polaroid with me, so I took a shot of it. He dropped out of college after just one semester and went to work as a copy boy for the Indianapolis Star Newspaper but returned to IU in the fall of 1967, and thats when he met his future wife, Julianna or Julie as she preferred to be called. But I would like to know the real answer to the question. Radersaid he liedto his wife, claiming it was a project he was working on about the BTK Killer for one of his college classes. Serial killers are master manipulators and experts at hiding in plain sight, and many have the ability to live double lives for years without getting caught. Mawson described their encounter at a bar in Seattle toPeople magazine:I thought, Hes good looking. He founded the Sav-a-Lot thrift stores and lived in the beautiful Fox Hollow estate. He was in turn described as a hotheaded boaster always trying to impress people, a perfectionist given to unprovoked rages, and a gregarious family man who loved old cars. Something Ive only shared with a handful of people until today. Herb was a domineering business partner, which Julie didnt like but tolerated. [00:18:30] In November of 1971, Herb was 24 years old, and he and Julia were married. Even for many of the wives of historys grisliest murderers, their husbands arrests came as a total shock. In June 1972, John WayneGacy married his second wife, Carol Hoff. In June of 1996 at the age of 49, Herbs life was continuing to crumble around him. [00:11:00] A neighbor of Baumeisters prompted a second search of Fox Hollow Farm. In the fall of 1994, Julie Baumeisters 13-year-old son found human remains on the familys $1 million estate, Fox Hollow Farm. Lynch filed for divorce from Robinson in 2005. Julie is related to Joyce Taglauer Green and Lori M Green as well as 3 additional people. This is all thats left. Make this guided journal your trusted friend during your journey to feeling whole again. Im Scott Benjamin and everything Im about to tell you is real. It seems that there was a lot that Herb Baumeister didnt tell his wife. Herb, of course, refused the search and since the police didnt have enough evidence for a warrant, they had to leave. [00:07:00] How he found a way to share his terrible secret with an entire group of onlookers, and he knew that none of them would ever report him to the police. In 2009, Fox Hollow Farm was bought by a couple with the perhaps grimly ironic last name Graves. They founded a prosperous business, the Sav-A-Lot Thrift Stores, their children attended private schools and to all appearances they had achieved According to the Chillicothe Gazette, weird things started happening about a year after the Graves family moved in. On June 24, 1996, while Herb was out of town, Julie allowed the police to search Fox Hollow Farm. All they had was a strong hunch that Baumeister was behind recent disappearances of gay men. WebJulie Baumeister told authorities that her husband made as many as 100 business trips to Ohio, on what he said was store business. As investigators combed his home and grounds, Baumeister disappeared. Herbs double life held a lot of secrets. [00:06:30] But that presents a problem for the killer. Scour the web for the tale of the I-70 Strangler, and the mannequins are always a footnote. He left a three-page note that talked of marriage and money woes, but not a word about the murdered men. It was apparent that Smart had done this before, and the man said that his hands were strong and confident around his neck as he strangled him to the edge of death. The excursion has been arranged by American Hauntings, a 25-year-old company that specializes in trips to some of the countrys spookiest places. But thats likely because he was a repeat offender with many prior convictions, and the judge reasoned that Dotsons [00:16:00] behavior, even though he never really harmed another human, struck fear in the community. However, since there was really no cause for alarm, [00:04:30] the two parted ways. Unlike these criminals, I can share this with you, but these killers couldnt allow anyone to know what they were up to. Linda later visited her husband in jail, asking him, Do you know why you killed these women? Listen to his interview and see if you agree. On May 25, 1969, authorities arrested Jerry and charged him with four murders and an additional two attempted murders. The poor thing deserved a better fate than that. He broke a lot of my furniture.. Days later, on July 3, 1996, his corpse turned up in Canada, an apparent suicide. "But, see, youre so close to somebody you dont see it.". Smart asked the informant to strangle him first, and he went along with it. Looking back, Linda said her husband did exhibit some suspicious behavior, but she had no idea he was a serial killer who preyed on sex workers. ' The pair married in 1988, andMawson referred to their marriage as a happy and blissful 13 years. I dont even like talking about psychics, but thats what they say. According to the Gazette, the psychics also say that the place is haunted by at least four of Baumeisters victims, not to mention Herb Baumeister himself. Not the kind of nightmares that a child might have, but the kind that can only come from the mind of a grown adult that seen a little too much real life horror, read a little too much of the macabre, and someone whos experienced a lot of recent pain and loss. And soon after when the authorities were knocking on her door and asking to search the property, she refused because Herb told her another lie. She also couldnt forget the human bones that her son had found on their property. Shortly afterward, Hoff filed for a divorce, which became finalized on March 2, 1976. The pair soon opened a second location, and things were beginning to look up for the young family. The informant tried to get Smart to talk more about the missing Goodlet, but every time he mentioned the missing man, Smart became evasive and changed the subject. And how you could have done this, and still be married to me?".