The Panel concluded that modified terephthalate polymers were safe as cosmetic ingredients in the practices of use and concentration described in this safety assessment. (Safety Assessment of Modified Terephthalate Polymers as Used in Cosmetics, April 12, 2013), Within the report, CIR stated, In several use tests of eye shadows, gels, liners, and mascara containing PET (up to 46.272%), there were few reports of adverse effects, including in subjects wearing contact lenses (Table 5). Referring to Table 5 says that there is a very slight ocular irritant potential with the eyeshadow used that is normal for this type of product.. I have some that I think are really cute from Shroud (formerly Strobe) Cosmetics, but because of concern for my eyes and the difficulty of removal, Ive been using them on my lips. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Combination skin. I am extremely happy not having to wear thick, thick glasses and being able to see at night. This makeup product is suitable for those who would like to create flawless cat-eyes, statement lines, and graphic wings. As others have said, I would never use one of the pressed glitters, but several of the more traditional shades/shadows you mentioned are in my collection! ColourPop has a very strict no return, refund or exchange policy, therefore if you are allergic to any of their products you will not be able to get your money back. there are things like mica, but that isn't glitter. Eyebrows. You can get a corneal abrasion or scratch on your eye through regularly-scheduled, mundane activities from inserting contact lenses (fingernails are often the culprits) to dust or sand getting into your eye to rubbing your eye. . Lightest, Neutral undertones. Very Light, Yellow, slight yellow undertones. This ColourPop review will take a close look at their most-loved products to help you decide if they are right for you. The younger ones may not know about primer and glitter glue and adhesives to keep the glitter adhering to the skin and end up with a corneal abrasion. In 2012, the FDA had replied to another media outlet with this: However, we are exercising enforcement discretion for a period of time. Lip Liner. COLOURPOP EYESHADOW QUESTION I recently discovered a new online American cosmetic company, Colourpop I was shopping on their website and noticed several products that are sold with their eyeshadows and liners that have the disclaimer "not for use around the eyes." You can then subscribe to their newsletter to get updated whenever there is a new deal on your favorite products. So what about metallic eyeshadow is that and foiled the same?? Your skin has pink, peachy pink, or red hues, Your skin has a balance of pink and yellow hues, Your skin has yellow, golden, or olive hues, Free Domestic Shipping on orders over $30, New Lav_ish Collection! Makeup palettes are gorgeous as expected, very pigmented and pretty good quality!! Where can I purchase Colourpop products and how can I be sure that Colourpop products are real? Thank you for all your research, what an eye opener! The products are also high-quality and effective! No Filter ColourPop Concealer features Cyclopentasiloxane, a silicone that evaporates quickly and makes the concealer dry fast. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an Also, high amounts of ingredients like fats, alcohol and waxes in lip liner, aren't exactly safe to use on eyes, per StyleCheer. A look into Bite Beauty's rebrand - is anything going right? Yes, I read it that way, too or at the very least, it certainly seemed like the merest fine print was not a 100% sure-fire way to avoid liability. LOL! The 100%-vegan-and-cruelty-free formula consists of marine ingredients that hydrate and protect your delicate under eyes. I have always gone for the expensive high end makeups but after Covid Ive been having to save where I can. I want to recommend a tip to anyone and everyone that use glitter, no matter what type or size it is: Remove it with tape. The quality of the makeup is fantastic!I'm so impressed with the color options and the overall visual beauty of the products. The more uniform edge, as opposed to natural mica, seems to be why brands feel comfortable using larger particle-sized synthetic mica than natural mica. Size: OS Colourpop. Shop on: Ulta Official Site Minor scratches can heal in a few days, whereas deeper ones can take longer, so seeing an eye doctor will allow them to look at the area and prescribe any necessary medications or provide treatment instructions for that specific case. Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Is there any danger in doing this? 2023 Trustpilot, Inc. All rights reserved. I wore both glitter eyeshadows on part of lower lash linesnot my waterlines but below my eyelineras past personal experience has given me more irritation from glitter fallout into my eyes (often requiring early removal of a look) when Ive worn it on my lid (I had no irritation during wear, only after removal). Apply tape (if its very sticky, remove a bit of the stickiness on the back of your hand) with light pressure on the glittery area and remove, and start again with fresh tape, and go on for as long as youve removed as much as you can. No, your eyes probably won't fall out but the chances of giving yourself a sty or other serious reaction dramatically increase (there's a reason we don't keep mascara for years, and those are formulated for eyes). We've done a little digging about the newest trend, so that you don't have to. Yes, as others have mentioned, you can use eyeliner as lip liner. Im sorry, Im not familiar with that ingredient! I am sorry to hear that you have experienced some eye issues as a result of your work on this blog, but I guess that it is not surprising, considering how much eyeshadow you apply on a daily/weekly basis, that one day you would be affected. So, I didnt want people to take what happened to me and run with it in an alarmist way either so I tried to present ALL the information possible so that it can be more about readers armed with whatever info is available and making the decision based on their personal comfort level. "These higher amounts are necessary so that the lip liner doesn't dry out your lips but can cause irritation and discomfort to the skin around your eyes.". I will be very cautious if I ever think of using glitter around my eyes again. Shop our blackest black, colorful, matte & metallic gel eye liners, liquid liners, and eyeliner pencils. Baby Powder. Craft glitter is an entirely different thing and absolutely should never be anywhere near the eye. Not sure where all the negative reviews came from. I cant believe they arent after the cosmetic companies if these products are not approved. , The cutest matte shade that we lilac a lot , Keep it cool with this icy metallic violet , Keep calm with this metallic pinky lavender , A duochrome lavender icy-blue for chill looks , Keep it sparkly with this metallic violet , A bright gold to pinky copper to metallic olivemulti chrome finish, A warm metallic bronze to gold to greenmulti chrome finish, Be an airbender with this multichrome red-copper-olive green , An earthbending multichrome gold-green-terracotta , Bend all the elements with this chromatic 4-piece set! It is a limited edition lip liner that retails for $5.00. Well that was a heck of a rabbit hole you jumped into. So while it appears to be similar to eyeliner, it definitely isn't the same and shouldn't be used interchangeably without taking the proper steps to ensure that you're using them safely. As a dry eye suffer who constantly has scratches on her cornea because theyre so dry (made worse from Lasik back then), the last thing I want are more scratches on my eyes. Size: OS Colourpop. The founders of ColourPop are siblings John and Laura Nelson, who originally branched out from Spatz Laboratories (their fathers makeup company) to launch Seed Beauty. This bronzer features super velvety-soft powders that add an attractive, natural-tanned glow to your face, especially when your skin appears dull. The reverse scenario, using eyeliner on your lips, is not quite as dire. In order to prevent this, they recommend only purchasing one item at a time and also checking the ingredients list. Your California Privacy Rights. Lips. So affordable too. Mascara. Your clarification would be appreciated and thank you again. Hi Christine ColourPop BFF Eyeliner is available in various colors such as white, canary yellow, true black, deep sapphire, dark brown, and bright bubblegum pink. is a light-medium, reddish-plum with warmer undertones and a matte finish. in the U.S. is obviously absurd and negligent. Combination skin. Thanks, Christina! Site is here -- http://thebeautybrains.com/2015/12/should-you-buy-organic-botox-from-kim-kardashian-episode-113/, http://thebeautybrains.com/2015/12/should-you-buy-organic-botox-from-kim-kardashian-episode-113/. Thank you once again Christine. I might be allergic to ColourPop products! In 2009, MAC glitters came with this warning: Keep entirely clear of eye area. FWIW, she thinks very highly of the Beauty Brains scientists, and their blog and podcast. Quality of eyeshadows is just as good as products that are twice the price. And Gute Besserung for your eye! The products are very high quality, but the package came damaged. Normal-to-Dry skin. Im so glad you didnt have permanent damage from this experience. Light Plus, Pink, moderately pink undertones. Having had a nasty little experience with Marc Jacobs Topaz Flash myself, I totally sympathize with you over your own experience with Fenty Rose Palette. I try to ignore the pressed glitters in my Colourpop palettes but it would be better if they werent in there at all. The purple liquid liner is perfection. However, the FDA has a Color Additives and Cosmetics Fact Sheet, and they go over special effects and novelty use, and they included this example (which sounds similar to the example provided in their response in 2012): Composite pigments: Color additives used in combination to achieve variable effects, such as those found in pearlescent products, are subject to the same regulations as all other color additives. Its incredible how very small particles can cause searing pain on the eye so magnified! Their collabs are always on point and stick to theme. ", The FDA takes this whole matter pretty seriously. Which is why Im so pleased that Christine put this post out. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Moondust doesnt include plastic glitter from what I recall, but you can always check the ingredient list UD is pretty good about posting theirs! Lash Primer & Serums. It had nearly opaque color coverage in one stroke, which adhered evenly to my lips and was comfortable to apply as a liner as well as all over my lips. BTW, I think you may be missing a clause after The FDAs position . View Privacy Policy. The items are available in limited quantities, and you cannot replace them with other products or credit. , As an eye care professional, I would like to say thank you from my heart for this! The Brella SweatControl Patch could be a game-changer for anyone with hyperhidrosis. Ive bought the hypoallergenic nars palettes before and my eyes stars watering and burning. liners And I guess colourpop for good alternatives for most of these things in fun colors. Baby Oil. It would be great if the world was kind and thoughtful, but it isnt. I really appreciate the work you put in to researching glitter in eye products, because it can feel so daunting as a layperson to sort through all the information from the FDA & the EU. Maybe the makeup companies will listen to you. Very Light, Olive, cool undertones. For example, ColourPop includes the warning "not intended for use in the immediate eye area" with their Pressed Glitters, which have been included in various palettes alongside eyeshadows and Pressed Pigments (another product "not intended for use in the immediate eye area"). The set includes the Mandalorian 9-Pan Pressed Powder Palette that features saturated neutrals, which enlivens and defines your eyes in just a single sweep, and rich, earth-toned shades, which flatters and makes you look more pulled-together. Lip Stain. Suitable for every skin tone, our ColourPop eyeshadow review found that this pigmented eyeshadow palette offers a range of color combinations to create that perfect eye look you have always wanted. Wow Christine! User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and I contacted the company and they said that the usage is up to consumer discretion and people are using these shadows on the eyes with no problems. Thanks for making sure your readers are informed about the products they purchase (or in some cases, ones we dont purchase.) So I hopped on the Google machine to see what the Internet had to say andcrickets. Colourpop never fails to come out with amazing new palettes and products. Everyone should have a good grasp of the general dos and donts of what to do if something gets in your eye, and if youre someone who regularly wears eye makeup, particularly anything with larger particles (like glitter), Id say its well-worth knowing what to do (or not do) before you need to know it! The other eye used Fenty eyeshadows from the Smoke and Pastel Frost palettes with the rest being the same. product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please IDK if products with that ingredient are made with less of a fine powder, or if there are chunkier ones available too. I occasionally get into researching about something thoroughly like you do (I chuckled with empathy at your reply to kjh The hours Ive spent with my eyes almost glazed over and two separate windows with 30-40 tabs open in each for the last three days trying to find clarity), but your results and conclusions (so thoughtfully and eloquently put) helps thousands of women and I commend you for that! Yes. I had LASIK surgery done a couple of years ago and my initial visit to see whether Id be a good candidate I was told my eyes were dry and that I wasnt a candidate. I've been wanting to try Colorpop for a long time. . I realized that the shadows are very persistent because I couldn't wash them off the table. I definitely have to remember to use mine daily! Find the top recommendations as voted by our Editor and community members here! Ive really only looked at finished cosmetics vs. raw ingredients, and it seems to turn up as polyethylene terephthalate. Id like to add my praise and thanks to everyone elses for this information and for the research youve done, Christine. Because their products do not cost a great deal, they do not offer returns, exchanges, or refunds once they have shipped an order. Look to see if any shades between two palettes are known dupes. Verification can help ensure real people write reviews about real companies. Yeah, I am bitter about it. Other glitters, like the stila liquid eyeshadows, Im fine. Thank you for posting about it and Im glad youre okay. I wish that they can offer free shipping on any order, so I can save money on shipping when I don't reach the minimum requirement for free shipping. The eyeliner has a cartridge of .55-ml ink encased in a stylish pen and contains butylene glycol to make the other ingredients spread out in their desired form for use. Seemingly, we appear to be extremely reliant on trusting brands to use ingredients that are safe in our cosmetics. I. COLOURPOP EYESHADOW QUESTION I recently discovered a new online American cosmetic company, Colourpop I was shopping on their website and noticed several products that are sold with their eyeshadows and liners that have the disclaimer not for use around the eyes. It looks like Colourpop is using red lakes that are not FDA approved for use around the eyes. Customer service takes a long time to reply but they refunded me very quickly although the value refunded was the discounted value of an item from a bundle. Normal skin. I thought that might be their secret sauce so I looked for dupes that had that ingredient and at the time I couldnt find any (I did purchase some of the Ambient Lights). A great, thoroughly researched post, even if its difficult to come to clear conclusionsbesides, for me anyway, avoid glitter. However, it became a bigger issue when I discovered that Im allergic to synthetic mica. The purple liquid liner is perfection. This particular formula may work better for simple lines along your lashes. This satin-finish bronzer comes in a 7-gram container, and you can apply it onto your jawline, temples, and cheeks for the perfect bronzed look. Im allergic to some glitters. Scotch tape to the rescue. Readers often ask me what are my absolute, all-time favorites, and now you can find my current and long-time favorites all in one place! Shop Now, Free International Shipping on orders over. Turns out you should never, ever use a lip liner as an eyeliner. Brands like NARS and Fenty have released pressed glitter eyeshadows, too, and I use the term eyeshadow because they, too, use the same term to describe those products; their palettes did not come with any warning/disclosure, and the packaging showed an eye icon. Unfortunately, there did not appear to be any color additive petitions about getting glitter approved for cosmetic use (let alone for eyes). Unlucky that it happened, but lucky how little damage it caused, despite all the pain while it was in there. thanks a lot no one is talking openly about it. Based on reading through all three reports, the final report on PET glitter didnt seem quite as detailed or as thorough to me, so Id certainly like to see more studies/tests done. Our ColourPop review found that the company offers international shipping, but orders are subject to duty fees and customs as defined by your country. Im happy to get cruelty-free, vegan products at a reasonable price.I was told about this company by my then teenage daughter. Because coconut water is rich in vitamins A, C, and K, it helps promote collagen production for healthier-looking skin. Dry skin. I have worn glitter products for years, too, on the lid as well as below the lash line (not the waterline) not always fully aware of the risks but quite aware of potential risks in the last few years. Duplicate a high-end product or never buy the same shade twice. You made my brain hurt reading this. Those concerns continue to be expressed more frequently as more brands include glitter in their product offerings, including products that may or may not be explicitly marketed for eyes but often are included in palettes that otherwise look like a typical eyeshadow palette. Lipstick. ColourPop Cosmetics products are cruelty-free, meaning that they are 100% animal-friendly, and the brand only tests them on human beings. I actually tried to confirm with Lit that their glitters were eye safe, and they referred me back to my own warning notice posted on their glitters, so in a very roundabout way, they actually wouldnt confirm they were safe. With knowledge comes power! Very Light, Pink, slight pink undertones. All the different types of glitter, how are we supposed to know?! This is very important to me! My products have not yet arrived at my house and I have waited more than 20 days. Wow. Very systematic, referring to precedents, etc. Hi Christine have been reading up about ingredients diligently ever since I discovered this post. All rights reserved. I Fell in love with Colorpops powders and lippies! This is excellent research, Christine! Im very happy with with all of my purchases so far. ColourPop Oh Snap Lippie Pencil. When I recently received a number of damaged items in my order, customer services responded within a day and refunded my order since the items could no longer be replaced. Im thinking that learning about all this is a good way for me to clean out my collection some more. I never had dry eyes to start but did have to rely upon drops for at least a couple years after surgery. Aww thats nice! They even caution against using a lip liner, or any makeup product not intended to be near your eyeball, in that general vicinity (you can read their eye-cosmetics safety guidelines here). Did your dry eyes ever get better post-Lasik, Christina? BrandRated is reader-supported. Whatever goes on my face is going near my eyes, too, but I dont use anything specifically for my eyes . Great read and I appreciate the work you put into this article. Thats what kind of scared me the most about it. As previously mentioned, there are two ingredients that are commonly used in cosmetics, including eye products, that might work in lieu of plastic glitter: borosilicate glasses and synthetic fluorphlogopite. Im sure it was a scary moment. I will never, ever order from colourpop ever again if customer service is that terrible. Im glad your eye was okay !! Here's what we found out. Oily skin. Thank you for the work you put into this! Signing up at this website is a breeze, as the entire registration process only takes a couple of seconds, and you only need to provide your basic details such as names, e-mail addresses, and passwords. Im personally not a fan of the new pressed glitter fad that many brands seem to be pushing, because the particles just seem too big & rough for me to feel comfortable putting near my eyes, even with glitter glue. Details How To Use Ingredients I got my item quick and easy since it was my first-time ordering form Colourpop. What makes one any safer than the other? Don't miss it Eyeshadow primer:." I had to wait for almost a year until my eye was moist enough though. The own thing that I wonder about is that if an eyeshadow palette is being sold with a color that states not to be used on the eye due to the glitter, what in the world do they expect you to use it for? Would you please be able to weigh in with your thoughts always love your insight and analysis of these topics! 4.0. Thank you so very much for investigating the PET conundrum, Christine. Is Colourpop breaking the law? The Foundation Matrix is designed to help. Food for thought as you make your own decisions. Especially since a good amount of glittery stuff seems to be marketed heavily towards that age catchment. Thank you ? The formula effortlessly glides across the puff of my under-eye. If you have any queries about ColourPop or their products, there are several ways that you can contact the support team. If irritation occurs, consult your ophthalmologist. In 2016, a kit of Pigments and Glitters had this warning for the Glitter and Reflects Glitter: Not for use in the eye area, though the Reflects line of Glitters contains calcium sodium borosilicate (not plastic glitter; other Glitters in the range do contain plastic glitter) and +/- color additives, while two Pigments included in the same kit also contain this ingredient but included additional ingredients beyond color additives. And disappointment. But if you insist on trying this lip liner TikTok hack, be sure to sanitize it with a cleanser that has alcohol in it and, if it is a pencil, try using a sharpener to clear the pencil of any contaminants before using it on your eyes. Per Allure,it's important to use caution when using this hack. Good luck. Outstanding piece, Christine. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) The product also features spherical light-diffusing powders designed to roll over your skin, allowing for even application and smooth blending while helping you avoid a cakey or dry look. Curate a Makeup Collection You Love with More Mindfulness (2022 Guide), How-to Buy Less Makeup: Guide to Makeup No-Buys & Low-Buys (2022). PET can be so dangerous when the particles are even the size yours or mine were. All you have to do is customize your routine and create your look. Additionally, ColourPop BFF Eyeliner contains Caprylyl Glycol, an ingredient that works as a preservative and prevents bacteria from growing to spoil the formula. Also, any color additives used in cosmetics must be approved by FDA. FDA on Makeup. It had nearly opaque color coverage in one stroke, which adhered evenly to my lips and was comfortable to apply as a liner as well as all over my lips. Lip Balm. There's no arguing with the fact that the end result looks great, but are makeup tools like lip liner, eyeshadow pigments, and other eye products, interchangeable? An example is a holographic glitter, consisting of aluminum, an approved color additive, bonded to an etched plastic film. We all super appreciate you. Shipping 60. You would think that it would be easy to ascertain if glitter was safe or if this ingredient was safe for this area or not, but alas, it is not so simple. Very Light, Olive, neutral undertones. And makeup *should* be care-free and fun. Colourpop isnt the only company making glitter eyeshadow. http://thebeautybrains.com/2015/12/should-you-buy-organic-botox-from-kim-kardashian-episode-113/. Only a sensation of grittiness if any fallout gets in my eye when I use that shade or the similarly textured Gilty Pleasure. FDA-regulated product. Looking for the best makeup and beauty products? Thank you, Hannah! Eye Makeup Remover. 5/$50 Brand New Colourpop OH SIS Lippie Pencil - Smoked Paprika Lip Liner. answered already. If you accidentally stab yourself in the eye with a mascara wand or eye brush that could cause damage to the eye. Normal-to-Dry skin. There are some derivatives like polybutylene, but it likely will have terephthalate with it. Our ColourPop review concludes by recommending this company because it is a reliable brand that offers high-quality products, great deals, and the website provides a good user experience. Oh my god!! Aside from the health concerns, its kind of odd to me that microbeads have become verboten but PET based glitters remain popular. The answer is pretty shocking.